Workshop on Cretaceous Climate and Ocean Dynamics

July 14-17, 2002

Florissant, Colorado, USA

Title:

Tropical environmental dynamics inferred from biotic dispersion patterns

Author:Claudia C. Johnson
Date Submitted:05/01/2002
Address:1001 E. 10th Street Bloomington
IN
USA
47405
Phone:812-855-0646
Email:claudia@indiana.edu
Co-Authors:
Affiliation:Indiana University, Bloomington
  
Abstract URL:http://cis.whoi.edu/science/GG/ccod/viewAbstracts.cfm?RefNumber=19725608
Keywords:tropics, colonial corals, rudist bivalves, reef lines, environmental dynamics
Abstract:Changes in the environment have modified the ecological role of reef builders through geologic time, and major extinctions have reset evolutionary patterns. In Cretaceous reefs, the relative ecologic role of scleractinian corals and rudist bivalves shifted during the middle Cretaceous, and rudist bivalves took over as the dominant skeletal organisms for the remainder of the period.

In previous works related to Cretaceous reefs, species diversity of rudist bivalves was quantified, reef lines based on the distribution of the bivalves were established on plate reconstructions, and fluctuations in the reef lines were interpreted in terms of thermal changes attributed to ocean heat transport. A dynamic rather than stable environmental history was proposed for the tropics, and the role of large-scale disturbance in the evolution of tropical ecosystems was proposed. However, the role of bivalves as proxies for reefal conditions remains questionable, and the time periods of the Cretaceous for which hypotheses of biotic change were proposed were temporally and geographically variable across the globe.

In this work, the geographic locations of scleractinian coral species were plotted for the Caribbean and circum-Caribbean region for all stages of the Cretaceous. Species occurrences were noted for each stage and plotted on present-day mercator maps. Occurrences were grouped and transferred per five degrees paleolatitude to the 130, 95 and 80 my plate tectonic reconstructions. Number of occurrences, number of species, and number of paleolatitude increments comprised the observed data base used for statistical analyses of colonial corals.

Results of the statistically analyzed coral database, and comparison to rudist bivalve data and interpretations, include the following. 1. Coral data fill in the reef line for the earliest Cretaceous stages. 2. The geographic extent of the Caribbean reef line defined initially on rudist bivalves was conservative. Colonial corals expand the paleolatitudinal extent of the tropics and display temporal patterns of geographic expansion and contraction similar to those expressed previously by rudists. 3. Dispersion patterns for corals and rudists infer that the geographic extent of the Cretaceous tropics was greater than that of our present-day interglacial period. 4. Knowledge of the paleolatitudinal extent of the ancient tropics is essential for analyzing the role of the tropics in ocean and atmospheric heat transport.

The larger-scale focus of this investigation is to question the driving mechanism for evolution in the tropics. A first-order inquiry concentrates on dynamic environmental conditions as opposed to tropical stability, and subsequent investigations analyze the processes driving tropical evolution under greenhouse versus icehouse conditions. Paleobiological questions center on macroevolutionary factors involving both the environment and the ecological characteristics of the co-existence of the two groups, specifically, morphologic and taxonomic changes expressed during the critical mid-Cretaceous faunal transition.